BCAA and muscle protein balance -
However, you need more total amino acids for things like bricks, insulation materials, or plumbing. BCAAs are a great start, but their efficacy can be limited by total amino acid availability.
The flip side of this scenario can also be seen when essential amino acids EAAs are taken without leucine. You can still get a small increase in protein synthesis, but with leucine is added back in, that increase is much greater Leucine could almost be seen as the foreman for the construction site.
For further proof, several studies have shown that adding additional amino acids to a leucine or BCAA dose can increase the protein synthesis response 3 , In addition, a study comparing a 25g dose of whey protein to a 6.
This particular study really underscores the importance of total amino acids when considering muscle protein synthesis spikes. So the above is more than likely one reason why people hate on BCAAs. What about the people who say BCAA intake is pointless in a high protein diet?
Studies examining the effects of BCAAs on recovery typically use g of BCAAs per day 15 , If we examine the average lb bodybuilder eating an optimal bodybuilding diet containing g of protein per day, how would their overall BCAA intake look before supplements?
The average protein consists of 4. Therefore, a bodybuilder consuming g of mixed proteins throughout the day ends up taking in about 8. However, how many normal people are actually able to get this much protein per day? But what about the rest of us? What about my wife, a registered nurse in a huge hospital working at least hours at a time?
Studies show that, while eating a protein-rich meal can increase protein synthesis, this effect only lasts for about 3-hours Interestingly enough, total amino acid availability is still pretty high 3-hours after a meal, but protein synthesis still drops off.
So what gives? This period is more so predicated on the cellular energy state of the muscle Like we mentioned in the BCAAs and exercise section, BCAAs can provide cellular energy.
Taking leucine 2-hours after a meal has actually been shown to keep protein synthesis at maximum levels whereas not supplementing with leucine results in synthesis rates dropping back to baseline about 3-hours after a meal So how exactly is this information useful?
Why not just take a protein shake instead? A protein shake or BCAAs? Where do you have to keep milk? In the refrigerator. In the employee break room. What does my wife rarely have time for? A break. However, most BCAA supplements mix just fine in water. Her breakfast of eggs, toast, and bacon will only ramp protein synthesis up for so long, so having that BCAA shake 3-hours later can help keep her gains rolling during her busy work day.
Chugging your BCAA shake will also be more beneficial than sipping it since your goal is to maximize protein synthesis a few hours after a meal. When else could BCAA supplementation be important? Have you ever heard of a diet? Energy balance — calories in vs calories out.
Consuming carbohydrates 2-hours after a meal can also help ramp protein synthesis back up as carbs will provide muscle cells with energy However, you would need about 10x the amount of carbohydrates compared to leucine to get this effect Since ~3. Repeat times a day for a few weeks and you might actually gain a pound or two.
Not exactly the goal of a diet, right? Plus, the most convenient form of carbohydrate for someone like my wife would be a sugary drink like Gatorade or even soda. Prior to the start of data collection all procedures were given institutional research ethics approval and subsequently registered as a clinical trial ClinicalTrials.
gov , NCT Experimental design and a flow diagram of the participants allocation to groups. The supplementation protocol followed a randomised, double-blind, placebo controlled design. The BCAA supplement Myprotein, Cheshire, UK contained a ratio of leucine, isoleucine and valine, respectively.
Artificial sweetener rather than a carbohydrate-based placebo was used to prevent a rise in insulin that may have altered protein metabolism [ 22 ]. In accordance with previous work [ 21 ], all participants were strongly advised to maintain regular dietary habits and avoid taking additional protein or any supplements for the duration of the study.
In an attempt to control for diet, participants were asked to record food intake in the loading phase of the trial and replicate this diet as closely as possible following the damaging protocol.
Participants performed a total of drop-jumps from a height of 0. Upon landing, participants were encouraged to immediately jump vertically with maximal force.
This protocol has been previously shown to cause significant elevations in muscle damage indices [ 19 , 27 , 28 ]. Plasma CK was determined from an earlobe capillary blood sample. The sample was analysed immediately using an automated, dry slide photospectrometer Reflotron Plus, Bio Stat Ltd.
Stockport, UK. Similarly to previous work [ 5 , 11 , 27 ], participants were seated on a plinth where the strain gauge was assembled. The strain gauge was attached to the ankle, immediately above the malleoli.
Each MVC was performed at a knee joint angle of 90 0. The joint angle was assessed prior to each repetition with a goniometer Bodycare Products, Warwickshire, UK at the lateral condyle of the femur.
Each participant was familiarised with the test procedure and received strong verbal encouragement for each attempt. Three MVCs were recorded and the maximum value was used for data analysis.
To account for inter-subject variability, MVC was expressed as a percentage of pre-damage MVC. Vertical jump VJ performance was assessed using the Vertec instrument Sports Imports, Columbus Ohio. Participants performed a counter movement jump in which, on command from a standing position, they descended rapidly to approximately a 90° knee angle and performed a maximal vertical jump, tapping the device with the dominant arm [ 30 ].
Each participant was familiarised with the test procedure prior to the recorded efforts and received strong verbal encouragement for each attempt.
Mid-thigh and calf circumference was assessed as a measure of limb swelling using an anthropometric tape measure Bodycare Products, Warwickshire, UK. Both measures were obtained with the participant in a standing position.
The calf measurement was made at the widest part of the calf, whereas the mid-thigh measure was determined as the mid-point between the inguinal crease and superior aspect of the patella. Both sites were marked with semi-permanent ink to ensure consistent measurements between days [ 27 ].
Detection of differences were determined using a 2-way, repeated measures ANOVA group, 2; time, 5. Significant interactions were followed-up using LSD post-hoc , pair-wise comparisons.
L -1 , respectively , which equated to a 3 to 4-fold increase above baseline. The initial aim of the present study was to examine the effects of BCAA supplementation on indices of muscle damage in resistance-trained volunteers.
The principle findings show BCAA can reduce the negative effects of damaging exercise by attenuating CK efflux, reducing residual muscle soreness and improving recovery of muscle function to a greater extent than a placebo control.
The protocol successfully induced muscle damage, which was evident from the significant time effects for all dependent variables. This supports the efficacy of the protocol as a model to induce muscle damage in a sport specific manner [ 27 , 28 ]. Additionally, the data presented here support previous literature suggesting BCAA as an effective intervention to reduce the negative effects of damaging exercise [ 15 — 18 ] and more specifically from damaging resistance exercise [ 14 , 20 , 21 ].
The novel information offered by these data demonstrate that BCAA can be used as an effective intervention to ameliorate the negative effects EIMD precipitated from a sport specific damaging bout of resistance exercise in trained participants.
However, the cell membrane is likely to have undergone some degree of lipolysis as a result of an imbalance in calcium homeostasis [ 4 ], almost certainly from the exercise insult. The damage literature often shows a high degree of inter-subject variability in CK and other cytosolic markers of EIMD, however, variability in the current study was relatively small, partly attributable to the trained status of the volunteers.
The greater conditioning of these participants has almost certainly led to a repeated bout effect [ 31 ], whereby, a conditioning bout of exercise in this case prior training leads to a decrease in damage indices on subsequent bouts [ 4 , 31 , 32 ].
This is further supported by the low CK response seen in both groups following the exercise, when compared to the damage responses seen in untrained volunteers [ 19 , 20 ]. Despite this relative homogeneity, the CK response was less in the BCAA group suggesting the membrane integrity was maintained to greater extent than the placebo group.
The damage response is known to be bi-phasic in nature; a primary response caused by the mechanical stress of the exercise, followed by a secondary, transient inflammatory response over the following hours and days [ 4 ].
Although we cannot definitively support this postulate, it seems plausible that the greater bioavailability provided by BCAA facilitated this response and thereby decreased secondary damage to the muscle.
Furthermore, the group effects support previous data [ 20 , 21 , 34 ] showing a reduction in muscle soreness following a damaging bout of exercise with BCAA supplementation. Although the mechanism surrounding muscle soreness following a damaging bout of exercise is not well understood, it seems likely to be related to inflammation, particularly to the connective tissue elements [ 35 ] that sensitise nociceptors in muscle and hence increase sensations of pain [ 36 ].
However, previous work [ 20 ] demonstrating a reduction in soreness following BCAA supplementation also measured the acute inflammatory response interleukin-6, a pro-inflammatory cytokine and showed no difference between the BCAA and placebo groups.
Jackman et al. Although this idea is somewhat speculative and has no supporting evidence or proposed mechanism, we show similar trends in our data, but it is not possible to support or refute this theory. Based on the reductions in CK, it makes the expectation tenable that the secondary damage phase is reduced by the aforementioned uptake of BCAA for protein synthesis, thus, limiting the extent of damage and hence reducing the precipitation of soreness.
Whilst there was no difference in vertical jump performance and limb girth, the most notable finding is that reductions in MVC were attenuated and recovery of MVC was accelerated following BCAA supplementation. This study demonstrated an effect on function and is in contrast to other work [ 20 ] that used untrained participants in a similar experimental design showing no benefits in the recovery of force production with BCAA.
Interestingly, other studies [ 21 , 37 ] using non-resistance-trained student populations have shown some benefit in the recovery of muscle function.
These data should be treated with caution however, as both studies [ 21 , 37 ] used a cross-over design which suffers the limitation of the repeated bout effect RBE. The RBE refers to a protective effect or attenuation of damage indices when the exercise is repeated [4,31,32].
It would seem that differences between our findings and those of Jackman et al. The other obvious difference between the current investigation and previous literature is the amount of BCAA administered.
Interestingly, Jackman et al. Previous work [ 39 ] has shown that timing of a protein based recovery strategy is important and immediately following a damaging bout of exercise can be most beneficial in accelerating recovery.
Whist Jackman et al. This is somewhat conjectural and would serve as an interesting question for future research to ascertain the optimal strategy for BCAA supplementation. Regardless of whether the loading phase and timing of the supplementation post-exercise was effective in increasing the bioavailability of BCAA, there is still a stark difference in the total supplementation volume 88 vs.
The larger quantity of BCAA we provided might partly account for the difference between studies in damage indices MVC and CK. We based our supplementation regimen on previous work that showed a positive effect [ 16 , 26 ] and propose that positive effects beyond attenuation of muscle soreness i.
There are two limitations from the study, which need to be acknowledged. Firstly the lack of specific dietary control might have led to discrepancies in caloric and, more specifically, protein ingestion between the groups.
Although we attempted to control this by asking participants to record food intake during the loading phase and replicate this following the damaging exercise, an approach that has been previous used [ 11 , 21 ], there was no specific control between groups.
Conceivably discrepancies in protein intake can affect the bioavailability of the substrate and hence affect protein turnover and ultimately influence the outcome of these data.
Although the current investigation has a good degree of external validity, future research might like to consider more rigorous dietary control measures such as; 1 asking participants to weigh food and accurately log food intake; or 2 providing a pre-determined menu for the participants to ensure no discrepancies between and within groups, although this still relies on participant adherence outside the laboratory.
Finally, 3 although difficult to facilitate, participants could be housed in an environment where dietary behavior can be imposed and thereby strictly controlled.
In summary, these data offer novel information on the application of BCAA supplementation. Most importantly, BCAA attenuated reductions in muscle function and accelerated recovery post-exercise in a resistance-trained population.
Adams GR, Cheng DC, Haddad F, Baldwin KM: Skeletal muscle hypertrophy in response to isometric, lengthening, and shortening training bouts of equivalent duration. J Appl Physiol. Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar. Higbie EJ, Cureton KJ, Warren GL, Prior BM: Effects of concentric and eccentric training on muscle strength, cross-sectional area, and neural activation.
CAS PubMed Google Scholar. Hortobagyi T, Hill JP, Houmard JA, Fraser DD, Lambert NJ, Israel RG: Adaptive responses to muscle lengthening and shortening in humans. Howatson G, van Someren KA: The prevention and treatment of exercise-induced muscle damage. Sports Med. Article PubMed Google Scholar.
Howatson G, Hough P, Pattison J, Hill JA, Blagrove R, Glaister M, Thompson KG: Trekking poles reduce exercise-induced muscle injury during mountain walking. Med Sci Sports Exerc. Article Google Scholar. Paschalis V, Nikolaidis MG, Giakas G, Jamurtas AZ, Pappas A, Koutedakis Y: The effect of eccentric exercise on position sense and joint reaction angle of the lower limbs.
Muscle Nerve. The aim of resistance or strength training is to make the muscle stronger by altering its structure and often involves muscle growth i.
muscle hypertrophy. Given that the BCAAs are especially important in stimulating muscle protein synthesis i. Indeed, consuming a sub-optimal dose of whey protein but supplemented with additional BCAAs can induce equivalent rates of muscle protein synthesis to that induced by 25 g of whey protein 7, 8.
In this way, muscle protein breakdown can be reduced during exercise and muscle protein synthesis can be increased in the recovery period. BCAA supplementation with endurance training may also facilitate adaptations in aerobic power and post-exercise recovery in trained athletes 9.
The store will not work correctly in the case when cookies are disabled. Skip to content. The Science Behind BCAAs — Part 2 Posted on May 25, November 21, Product Guides by Ted Munson Performance Nutritionist. What are BCAAs? What do they do? When can they be used?
Are they good to use during resistance training? What about endurance sports? Endurance training: BCAAs are used to contribute to energy production during exercise especially if undertaken with low carbohydrate availability. Consuming BCAAs prior to or during endurance exercise can therefore reduce muscle protein breakdown whilst also promoting muscle protein synthesis in the post-exercise recovery period.
References Kephart, W. Ten weeks of branched-chain amino acid supplementation improves select performance and immunological variables in trained cyclists.
Amino Acids , 48 3 , Pasiakos, S.
Metrics details. Branched-chain amino acids BCAAs; Sports psychology for eating disorders, balacne, and isoleucine are essential amino acids rpotein protein anabolic properties, Liver health and gut health connection have BCAA and muscle protein balance studied in valance number of muscle wasting protien for more than 50 years. However, until Sports psychology for eating disorders, there is no consensus regarding their therapeutic effectiveness. In the article is demonstrated that the crucial roles in Baalance metabolism play: BCAAA skeletal muscle as the initial site of BCAA catabolism accompanied with the release of alanine and glutamine to the blood; ii activity of branched-chain keto acid dehydrogenase BCKD ; and iii amination of branched-chain keto acids BCKAs to BCAAs. Enhanced consumption of BCAA for ammonia detoxification to glutamine in muscles is the cause of decreased BCAA levels in liver cirrhosis and urea muscl disorders. Increased BCKD activity is responsible for enhanced oxidation of BCAA in chronic renal failure, trauma, burn, sepsis, cancer, phenylbutyrate-treated subjects, and during exercise. Decreased BCKD activity is the main cause of increased BCAA levels and BCKAs in maple syrup urine disease, and plays a role in increased BCAA levels in diabetes type 2 and obesity. For some reason unbeknownst to our team here at The MusclePhD, branched-chain amino acids BCAAs aand really become a subject Sports psychology for eating disorders pdotein debate BCAAA the fitness Vitamins for womens health. But open your mind up a little bit. Who are BCAAs trash for? Should everyone throw their BCAAs in the garbage? Branched-chain amino acids consist of 3 amino acids: leucine, isoleucine, and valine. All 3 BCAAs are considered essential amino acids in that you have to get them from your diet; your body cannot make its own BCAAs
0 thoughts on “BCAA and muscle protein balance”